Home

Elementary Discussions

/r/Elementary 6958 subscribers

A modern take on the cases of Sherlock Holmes, with the detective now living in New York City.

Jump to season: 1 3 4 5 6 7 1 2 3 4 5 6

S1E2

Episode 2/22 Paint It Black Episode Discussion 77 comments
Episode 2/20 "No Lack of Void" Episode Discussion 14 comments
Episode 2/19 "The Many Mouths of Andrew Colville" Discussion 23 comments

S3E14

Episode 3x14-The Female of the Species Discussion 81 comments

S3E24

*SEASON FINALE* Episode 3x24-A Controlled Descent Discussion 89 comments

S4E1

Season 4x01-Past is Parent discussion and review 70 comments

S4E7

Episode 4x07- Miss Taken Discussion and Review 78 comments

S4E16

Episode 4x16 "Hounded" Discussion and Review 34 comments

S4E17

Episode 4x17- "You've Got Me Who's Got You" Discussion and Review 43 comments

S4E18

Episode 4x18 "Ready or Not" Discussion and Review 60 comments

S4E19

[DOUBLE HEADER TONIGHT] Episode 4x19 & 4x20 Discussion and Review 61 comments

S4E22

Episode 4x22-Turn It Upside Down Discussion and Review 49 comments

S4E24

*Season Finale* Episode 4x24 A Difference In Kind Discussion and Review 62 comments

S5E1

*Season Premiere* Episode 5x01-Folie A Deux Discussion and Review 21 comments

S5E2

Episode 5x02 "Worth Several Cities" Discussion and Review 40 comments

S5E3

Episode 5x03 "Render, and Then Seize Her" Discussion and Review 26 comments

S5E4

Episode 5x04 - Henny Penny The Sky is Falling Discussion and Review *Episode 100!* 22 comments

S5E6

Episode 5x06- Ill Tidings Discussion and Review 47 comments

S5E7

Episode 5x07- Bang Bang Shoot Chute Discussion and Review 17 comments

S5E9

Episode 5x09 "It Serves You Right To Suffer" Discussion and Review 20 comments

S5E13

Season 5 Episode 13 Discussion "Over a Barrel" 51 comments

S5E16

Season 5x16 - "Fidelity" Episode Discussion Thread 39 comments

S5E23

Episode 5x23- "Scrambled" Discussion and Review 113 comments

S5E24

**Season Finale** Episode 5x24-Hurt Me, Hurt You Discussion and Review 128 comments
Season 5x24-"The Twelfth Step Problem" Discussion and Review 7 comments

S6E3

Episode 6x03-"Pushing Buttons" Post-Episode Discussion and Review 31 comments

S6E4

Episode 6x04- Our Time Is Up post episode discussion and review 38 comments

S6E5

Episode 6x05 "Bits and Pieces" Discussion and Review 41 comments

S6E6

Episode 6x06 "Give Me The Finger" Discussion and Review 40 comments

S6E7

Episode 6x07, "Sober Companions" Pre-show thread and Live Discussion 0 comments

S6E8

Episode 6x08 "Sand Trap" Post episode discussion and review 32 comments
Episode 6x8- "Sand Trap" Pre-Thread and Live Discussion 11 comments

S6E9

Episode 6x09- "Nobody Lives Forever" Post-Episode Discussion and Review 42 comments

S6E10

Episode 6x10 - The Adventure of the Ersatz Sobekneferu Post Episode Discussion and Review 65 comments
Episode 6x10-The Adventure of the Ersatz Sobekneferu Pre-Episode Discussion and Live Reactions 6 comments

S6E11

Episode 6x11 "You've Come A Long Way Baby" Discussion and Review 36 comments

S6E12

Episode 6x12- Meet Your Maker Discussion and Review 90 comments

S6E13

Episode 6x13 - 'Breathe' - Discussion & Review 42 comments

S6E14

Episode 6x14-"How to get a head" Discussion and Review 33 comments

S6E16

Episode 6x16 - 'Uncanny Valley of the Dolls' - Post Episode Discussion 43 comments

S6E17

Episode 6x17 "The Worms Crawl In, The Worms Crawl Out" Discussion and Review 31 comments

S6E18

Episode 6.18 - "The Visions of Norman P. Horowitz" Discussion and Review 63 comments

S6E19

Episode 6x19 "The Geek Interpreter" Discussion and Review 60 comments

S6E20

SPOILERS Post episode discussion. 6x20 132 comments

S6E21

Episode 6x21-"Whatever Remains, However Improbable" Discussion and Review 155 comments

S7E1

Episode 7x01-"The Further Adventures" Discussion and Review 50 comments

S7E2

Episode 7x02, "Gunshot" Discussion and Review 44 comments

S7E3

Episode 7x03 "The Price of Admission" Discussion and Review 42 comments

S7E4

Episode 7x04 - "Red Light, Green Light" Discussion and Review 29 comments

S7E7

Episode 7x07- "From Russia With Drugs" Discussion and Review 36 comments

S7E8

Episode 7x08- “Miss Understood” Discussion And Review 42 comments

S7E9

Season 7 Episode 9- "On The Scent" Discussion and Review 33 comments

S7E11

Season 7 episode 11 - "Unfriended" Discussion 119 comments

S7E12

Episode 07x12 "Reichenbach Falls" Discussion and Review 101 comments

S7E13

**SERIES FINALE!!!** Episode 7x13-Their Last Bow Discussion and Review 221 comments

SnullE10

Where is the episode 10 discussion post? 38 comments

S1E9

Elementary Season 1 Episode 9 Discussion: You do it to Yourself. 19 comments

S1E12

Episode 12 "M" discussion. 41 comments

S1E14

Elementary 1x14 The Deductionist Discussion(Live discussion and commentary, post-episode analysis) 30 comments

S1E16

Episode 16 "Details" Discussion. [Spoilers] 32 comments

S1E19

Discussion for 1x19 - 'Snow Angels' 26 comments

S1E22

Elementary: Episode 1x22 Discussion *Spoilers* 0 comments

S2E2

Elementary Season 2 Episode 2 - Solve for X - Discussion 18 comments

S2E3

Elementary S02x03 - We Are Everyone - Discussion 57 comments

S2E4

Elementary S02x04 - Poison Pen - Discussion 20 comments
I've forgotten a pertinent (to S2E04) bit of Holmes' backstory, could anyone help me out? 2 comments

S2E16

S02E16-The One Percent Solution 36 comments

S3E1

Episode 3x1-Enough Nemesis to Go Around Discussion 39 comments

S3E2

Episode 3x2-The Five Orange Pipz Discussion 13 comments

S3E3

Episode 3x03- Just a Regular Irregular Discussion 15 comments
Elementary Podcasts for 3x03, "Just a Regular Irregular" 0 comments

S3E4

What really happened at the end of the episode 3x4 "Bella" 2 comments
Season 3x4 "Bella" discussion 29 comments

S3E5

Season 3x5- "Rip Off" Discussion 34 comments

S3E6

Season 3x6- "Terra Pericolosa" Discussion 24 comments

S3E7

Episode 3x7- The Adventure of the Nutmeg Concoction 14 comments

S3E8

Episode 3x8 End of Watch Discussion 36 comments

S3E10

Episode 3x10-Seed Money Discussion 8 comments

S3E11

Episode 3x11, The Illustrious Client Discussion 72 comments

S3E12

Episode 3x12-The One That Got Away 70 comments

S3E13

Episode 3x13-Hemlock discussion 79 comments

S3E16

Episode 3x16 For all you know discussion 41 comments

S3E18

Elementary 03x18-The View from Olympus Discussion 35 comments

S3E19

Elementary 3x19 One Holmes One Watson Discussion 15 comments

S3E20

Elementary 3x20- A Stitch in Time Discussion 27 comments

S3E21

Episode 3x21-Under My Skin diiscussion 22 comments

S3E22

Elementary 3x22- The Best Way Out Is Always Through Discussion 28 comments

S3E23

Season 3x23-Absconded Discussion 23 comments

S4E2

Episode 4x02-Evidence of Things Not Seen 32 comments

S4E3

Episode 4x03 Tag, You're Me Discussion and Review 28 comments

S4E4

Episode 4x04- All My Exes Live in Essex discussion and review 47 comments

S4E5

Elementary s4x05-The Games Underfoot Discussion and Review 19 comments

S4E6

[Last episode of 2015!] S4e06-The Cost of Doing Business Discussion and Review 31 comments

S4E8

Episode 4x08 "The Burden of Blood" Discussion and Review 30 comments

S4E9

Episode 4x09 "Murder Ex Machina" Discussion and Review *Clyde Watch* 41 comments

S4E13

Elementary Episode 4x13 "A Study in Charlotte" Discussion and Review 20 comments

S4E14

Season 4 episode 14 "Who is that Masked Man" Discussion and Review 24 comments

S4E15

Episode 4x15- "Up to Heaven and Down To Hell Discussion" and Review 16 comments

S4E21

Episode 4x21 Ain't Nothing Like The Real Thing discussion and review 22 comments

S5E5

Episode 5x05 - To Catch a Predator Predator Discussion and Review 17 comments

S5E10

Season 5x10 "Pick Your Poison" Discussion and Review 24 comments

S5E11

Season 5x11 "Be My Guest" Discussion and Review *Plus some Meta stuff to talk about* 36 comments

S5E14

Season 5x14- "Rekt in Real Life" Discussion and Review 33 comments

S5E15

Season 05x15-"Wrong Side of the Road" Discussion and Review 56 comments

S5E17

Meat Loaf in S5E17 3 comments

S5E19

Season 5x19- "High Heat" Discussion and Review 46 comments

S6E1

We're Back! Season 6x01- "An Infinite Capacity for Taking Pains" Pre-Show and Live Thread 32 comments

S6E2

Episode 6x02- "Once You've Ruled Out God" Pre-show and live thread 11 comments